When it came to Monday's post about spring training highlights trumping spring stats, that's admittedly a luxury not everybody afford. Beyond a boost of confidence or a chance to address issues before the stats start counting for good, a good spring or bad spring doesn't mean anything to Tim Anderson, Yoan Moncada, or, strangely, Adam Engel. Eloy Jimenez might want to step it up to make Rick Hahn's dance an awkward one, but he's starting the season in Charlotte either way, because as we learned from the Manny Machado failure, the White Sox are gravely concerned about their payroll seven years from now.
But for fringe candidates -- especially ones who are out of options -- it's in their interest to make the decision a tough one for a Rick, be it Hahn or Renteria.
Most of the out-and-out roster battles are in the bullpen this year, and the pitchers aren't really keeping each other honest. The White Sox have an Arizona-as-hell record of 3-6-2, thanks in part to Arizona-as-hell pitching lines. More than one-third of the pitchers used by the White Sox in the spring own double-digit ERAs, including some who entered the spring on the outside looking in, but had a puncher's chance. Look at this cross-section of the White Sox stats page:
It's one thing to have a spring like Reynaldo Lopez, who is giving up his share of flares. The bad contact luck is why everybody would like to see him hike his strikeout rate, but he's throwing strikes and throwing sliders, which is the important thing. At the bottom of the list, Kelvin Herrera's one ugly outing also merits a shrug at this point, because he's owed more money than any other White Sox offseason acquisition if nothing else.
In between?
- Randall Delgado, who could replace Hector Santiago as a swingman but has given up four homers in five innings.
- Carson Fulmer, whose return to his Vanderbilt windup hasn't increased the power of his stuff.
- Jace Fry, Caleb Frare and Aaron Bummer, the latter two of whom are competing for the same second lefty spot.
- Juan Minaya, who is testing the saving grace of his regular-season experience and lack of options.
You can also lump in Manny Banuelos, whose spring took a wrong turn after he walked four Cubs in an inning on Sunday. He's got a head start on Ervin Santana as the latter pitches himself into game shape, but he's not doing much with it, as his 8.10 ERA attests.
Banuelos is out of options, so a terrible spring isn't the worst thing in the world if it allows the Sox to sneak him through waivers for rotation depth in Charlotte. But in order for that to be useful, the White Sox will need to see tenable stuff from Santana. If both pitchers appear sound, Banuelos could occupy one of the lefty bullpen jobs if Frare and Bummer can't find the zone. If both pitchers struggle ... well, hopefully you still have your calluses from the 2018 season.
On the flip side, Dylan Covey has thrown two pairs of scoreless innings with a lively sinker. As long as the White Sox don't need him to face an order a second time through, he can be a multi-inning reliever on a rebuilding team, so Delgado will have to step it up. Ryan Burr has been the most effective reliever on the 40-man roster, with Zach Thompson on the outside looking in. (Ian Hamilton has yet to appear, as he's dealing with stiffness after a car accident.)
If spring training ended today and you were to try to assemble a bullpen based on spring performances and contractual obligations, it turns into a bit of a mess after five spots:
| Preseason | Merit/obligation |
| Colome | Colome |
| Herrera | Herrera |
| Jones | Jones |
| Minaya | Burr |
| Fry | Covey |
| Frare/Bummer? | Fry? |
| Hamilton? | Banuelos? |
| Delgado? | Minaya? |
Fortunately for most involved, the Cactus League still has nearly a full three weeks remaining, including split-squad action that should give a lot of them a chance to start something better. The relievers carrying middle-school ERAs can give up on having a pretty spring training line, but the big-picture dream still remains alive otherwise.
